by Eojin Park ’28
Introduction
When Japan formally annexed Korea in 1910, it did not merely impose foreign rule on a peninsula—it set into motion a generation of activists and intellectuals who would spend the next four decades debating, organizing, and sometimes fighting one another over the question of what a liberated Korea ought to look like. Among those who channeled that sense of urgency to achieve liberation through American higher education, two Princeton alumni stand out not only for their prominence but for the divergence of their political visions: Channing Liem (임찬휘), who received his A.M. in 1943 and his Ph.D. in 1946, and Syngman Rhee (이승만), who earned his Ph.D. from Princeton in 1910. Both were shaped by the American institutions they passed through; moreover, both believed fervently in Korean independence. And yet, in their understanding of governance, authority, and the meaning of liberation itself, they arrived at almost irreconcilable conclusions — conclusions that would eventually define the political landscape of a divided Korea.

This post traces the arc and denouement of that disagreement through the lives and careers of these two men, situating them within the broader context of the Korean independence movement in the United States. In doing so, it draws in part on Princeton’s archival holdings—particularly graduate alumni records and related library materials—which offer valuable insight into the institutional lives of these figures. There are also additional figures introduced in this essay who remain less studied but equally deserving of scholarly attention, in the hope that their stories, too, will one day be more fully told.
The Korean Independence Movement in America
To understand the conflict between Liem and Rhee, one must first understand the world that produced them both. The Korean independence movement in the United States was not a monolithic enterprise but a fractured, energetic coalition of overlapping organizations, personalities, and ideological commitments. At its institutional core stood the Korean National Association (대한인국민회), organized on February 1, 1909 in San Francisco, with the stated mission of representing “all Korean interests in the United States.” Alongside it, the 흥사단 (Young Korean Academy), founded by An Ch’ang-ho (안창호), emphasized moral cultivation and grassroots organization as the proper foundation for future nationhood.
The movement’s activities were concentrated in Hawaii and San Francisco, where activists raised funds, lobbied the U.S. government, organized community networks, and published newspapers. Their strategic toolkit was at once pragmatic and idealistic: they worked to frame Japanese colonial rule as a violation of international law and human rights, cultivated relationships with American missionaries and journalists, and pressed their case before a largely indifferent U.S. Congress. The 1919 March First Movement — in which Korean civilians took to the streets across the peninsula in nonviolent protest against Japanese occupation — galvanized the diaspora and briefly drew international attention, though it ultimately failed to produce the diplomatic recognition Korean activists sought.
Within this movement, three figures loomed largest: Syngman Rhee (이승만), An Ch’ang-ho (안창호), and Pak Yong-man (박용만). Each represented a distinct theory of how independence was to be achieved and, crucially, what kind of polity was to be built in its aftermath. It is in this context—of competing visions, rival factions, and divergent understandings of Korean sovereignty—that Channing Liem’s later critique of Rhee gains its full significance.
Syngman Rhee at Princeton and His Later Rise to Power

Between Liem and Rhee, Rhee is the better-known alum. Syngman Rhee arrived in the United States already having experienced imprisonment and exile. Born in 1875, he had been jailed by the Korean royal government for his reformist activities before being released and traveling abroad. His intellectual trajectory at American universities—undergraduate work at George Washington University, graduate study at Harvard, and ultimately a Ph.D. in International Law from Princeton in 1910—made him, by any measure, one of the most credentialed Korean political figures of his era.
At Princeton, archival materials preserved in Princeton’s graduate alumni records indicate that Rhee’s dissertation focused on the influence of Christianity upon political thought, reflected an intellectual synthesis that would remain characteristic of his career: the belief that Western democratic forms and Christian moral values were not only compatible with Korean nationhood but essential to it. At the same time, these records primarily document his academic positioning rather than offering a complete picture of how these ideas translated into political practice. However, the dissertation at least hints that for Rhee, embodying American ideals was not mere strategy—it was a template for how a modern Korea ought to be organized.
Throughout his years leading the Korean independence movement abroad, Rhee consistently favored centralized authority and resisted coalition governance—a leadership style which was likewise documented in the Graduate Alumni Records. When liberation finally came in 1945 and the United States occupied the southern half of the peninsula, Rhee’s combination of anticommunist fervor and American credibility made him, in the eyes of U.S. military authorities, the “ideal” choice for leadership.
Channing Liem’s Life, Faith, and Dissenting Vision
Born in Pyongyang on September 9, 1909, Liem was in many respects a product of the same Korean Christian intellectual tradition that shaped so many of the students who passed through Princeton in the early twentieth century. His early education at the Union Christian College in Korea, his subsequent studies at Lafayette College (where he earned a B.S. in 1934 and won the gold medal for the Barge Oratorical Contest—a remarkable achievement for an international student from Pyongyang), and his years at the Biblical Seminary in New York all bespoke a formation deeply rooted in Protestant faith and scholarly discipline.
Princeton’s archival records provide glimpses into Liem’s graduate career, noting, for instance, that he lived at 33 Witherspoon Street, he was awarded the Sanxay Fellowship in Practical Ethics from 1942 to 1944, and received the Class of 1883 Fellowship in Politics from 1944 to 1945.
Between 1936 and 1941, before arriving in Princeton, Liem had served as pastor and director of the Korean Church and Institute in New York City. He was embedded in the Methodist congregational life of the Korean immigrant community, attuned to its pastoral needs, its organizational rhythms, its particular fusion of religious and political aspiration. When he wrote, in his own words, “I completed my studies in the Biblical Seminary while serving at its Korean Church… I shall receive a degree of S.T.B when I complete my thesis,” in his application to Princeton’s graduate school in political science, one hears not the calculation of a careerist but the reflection of someone who understood his scholarship as continuous with his service.
That formation gave Liem a vantage point from which to observe — and ultimately challenge — the settlement that brought Rhee to power. After Korea’s division, Liem served as the Republic of Korea’s ambassador to the United Nations from 1960 to 1961, a position that placed him at the center of the geopolitical structures that had shaped Korea’s fate. His subsequent work, including The Korean War: An Unanswered Question, offered a sustained critique of the choices made in the immediate postwar period: the exclusion of genuinely representative Korean political authority, the imposition of Rhee’s leadership by American military fiat, and the longer-term consequences of building a state on the foundation of anticommunism rather than democratic legitimacy.
As Channing Liem would later observe with pointed clarity, “In the US zone American authorities refused entirely to recognize any Korean authority… and eventually Syngman Rhee, largely on the basis of his staunch anticommunist outlook, was selected to lead South Korea even though General Hodge, commander of US forces in Korea, called him utterly unqualified.”
The animosity Liem expresses towards Rhee is evident here: Liem believed that Rhee was selected not because he commanded the broadest popular support, nor because he represented the most sophisticated vision of postwar governance, but because he fit most neatly into an emerging Cold War strategy on part of the U.S. Consequently, Liem believed that the democratic credentials he supposedly had—an education at Princeton among other U.S. institutions—were incongruous with what he thought was Rhee’s authoritarian values and eventual rule.
Liem was not a radical in the ideological sense — his lifelong Christian commitment and his willingness to serve in a South Korean diplomatic role attested to that. But he was, in the most precise sense of the word, a dissenter: someone who believed that the manner in which Korea had been organized after liberation had foreclosed possibilities that deserved to remain open, and that honest accounting required saying so.
Room for Further Research
The stories of Liem and Rhee are, in many respects, the most legible chapters of a larger archive that remains significantly underexplored. Princeton’s Korean alumni of the early twentieth century include a number of figures whose lives intersected with the independence movement in ways that deserve sustained scholarly attention.

- Kei-won Chung *38, who resided in 118 Brown Hall and worked with Nancy Lee Swann at the Gest Oriental Library, represents another form of cultural activism. In a letter dated March 8, 1938, Chung expressed his desire to “leave some worthy things in your library before I leave Princeton,” feeling strongly that “your library should have some Korean books.” His dual role as a cultural ambassador—working to place Korean texts in Princeton’s collections while simultaneously serving as Principal Translator of Japanese for the U.S. Office of Censorship beginning February 1, 1943—illuminates the complex position of Koreans in wartime America: simultaneously subjects of suspicion, instruments of military necessity, and guardians of a cultural heritage they feared might be erased.
- Hern Joo Song (송헌주), who earned his A.M. in History and Politics from Princeton in 1915 before enrolling at Princeton Theological Seminary, dedicated his life in the United States to resisting Japanese occupation—a commitment recalled with evident pride by his granddaughter Ki Kim in a 1988 letter.
- Julian Park (박준섭), who enrolled at Princeton in 1919 and pursued his M.A. while simultaneously attending Princeton Theological Seminary, represents the continuity of a Korean Christian scholarly network that stretched across institutions and decades.
These figures—pastor-scholars, cultural intermediaries, translators, activists—did not achieve the political prominence of Rhee or produce the critical literature of Liem. But they constituted the foundation of the Korean movement in the United States, through which the aspiration for Korean independence was sustained across years of disappointment and uncertainty. Their full stories remain to be told, and Princeton’s archives hold many of the threads.
Conclusion
Channing Liem’s dissent from Syngman Rhee’s political legacy was not the dissent of an outsider or an ideological opponent in any simple sense. It was the dissent of someone who had inhabited the same tradition—Christian, Korean, American-educated—and arrived, through the discipline of ethics and the experience of politics, at a different conclusion about what accountability required. That disagreement, registered in fellowship applications and pastoral correspondence and eventually in published critique, is itself a kind of historical document: a record of the possibilities that were present at the founding moment of modern Korea, and of the choices, some made by Koreans, many made by Americans, that foreclosed them.
The title of this essay borrows from a simple geographic fact—Liem and Rhee shared a country—to point toward a more complex historical reality: that sharing a national aspiration does not produce unity of political vision, and that the institutions through which people pass shape them in ways they cannot always anticipate or control. Princeton gave both men something. However, what each took from it, and what each made of it, could not have been more different.
Sources
Deede, Sara. “Activism and Identity: How Korea’s Independence Movement Shaped the Korean Immigrant Experience in America, 1905-1945,” M.A. thesis Portland State University, 2010.
Graduate Alumni Records (AC105)
Kim, Han-Kyo. “The Korean Independence Movement in the United States.” International Journal of Korean Studies 6, No. 1 (Spring/Summer 2002): 1-27.
Liem, Channing. The Korean War: An Unanswered Question. Pyongyang: Foreign Languages Publishing House, 1993.
Office of Communications Records (AC168)
Rhee, Syngman. Neutrality as Influenced by the United States. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1912.

